Latest update April 18th, 2024 12:59 AM
Dec 02, 2018 News
By Kiana Wilburg
Oil spills can result in long term damage to a nation. In some cases, the effects are irreversible. Considering this, international bodies have stressed on the need for regulators to ensure oil companies have “comprehensive” insurance that provides coverage for the eventualities that may arise from their operations.
One of the many advocates on this matter is the World Bank, one of Guyana’s development partners. According to the organization, it is expected that oil companies take out insurance for their operations in any country.
However, the World Bank warned that operators have often sought insurance which only covers certain activities. These may include third party legal liability and control of wells, re-drill, and cleanup of sudden and accidental pollution from a well out of control.
It cautioned that industry regulators must ensure that an operator’s insurance covers every possible eventuality since “for some operators, their insurance excludes blowout or subsurface pollution or below-wellhead risk.”
The World Bank highlighted that there is insurance that covers a blowout from an oil project. It is referred to as Operators’ Extra Expense (OEE) insurance.
The World Bank said that emerging oil producers such as Guyana would want to ensure that this is in place especially when one considers how other nations suffered in the absence of this.
In this regard, the financial institution cited the case of the major oil spill which occurred in 2010 in the Gulf of Mexico. The spill led to a loss of 53,000 barrels of oil a day for many weeks. It covered 6,500 square kilometers and involved five million barrels of oil. The source, the Deepwater Horizon field, was operated by BP under a joint operating agreement with Anadarko Petroleum and Mitsui Oil Corporation.
The financial consequence of the spill was more than US$8 billion since the insurance of the operator did not cover pollution following a blowout.
ADDRESSED FOR 2020
Guyana currently has no policy that provides guidance on whether oil companies should be allowed to self-insure or be made to lodge an internationally recognized insurance policy with the relevant authorities.
In the absence of clear direction, Head of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Dr. Vincent Adams, expressed the opinion that there could be varying implications for the sector.
During an exclusive interview with this newspaper, the Environmental Engineer insisted that this is an issue which must be addressed before 2020.
Dr. Adams said, “I am not sure if we are the only body which must decide on this matter. But I do know that we would have a say in it…Currently, the ExxonMobil-Guyana contract allows the company to self-insure. This means that the company has given us some assurance that it will handle the liabilities that come with any possible oil spill.”
The Engineer added, “Guyana must now decide if this is the route it wants to go for other oil companies. We must also consider the pros and cons of self-insurance versus having insurance policies.
In the USA, oil companies have to post a bond and provide an insurance policy…They also have to provide other things to the authorities to prove they can cover any liabilities…But in Guyana’s case, we need to decide the way forward. We need to ensure that companies, if they are going to operate here, they can guarantee sufficient coverage.”
Dr. Adams noted, however, that this is an issue which must be carefully analyzed. He said that there should be no hasty adoption of mechanisms that exist elsewhere.
He said, “I do believe that this is something that needs to be analyzed, it needs to be addressed, it needs to be regulated before 2020. As the lead regulator, I am for the principle that there must be a policy in place that states how we are to address this matter.”
The EPA head added, “I wish to state however that we should be cautious. Let us not just adopt willy-nilly, any sort of system or governing policies in other countries. We need to do our own risk analysis and tailor something that fits us.”
MAKE IT MANDATORY
Founding Director of the Agency for Security, Energy and the Environment (ASEA), Carlos De Regules has insisted that it would be in Guyana’s interest to make insurance policies mandatory for the oil and gas sector.
Regules said, “With self insurance, companies show their own balance sheet as a guarantee and that we (Mexico) will not accept as a valid guarantee. We always insist on having an insurance policy. Self insurance is not good enough. You must show a policy that is in line with international standards…”
Stressing the importance of insurance policies, the ASEA Director noted that there is an international law or understanding that you cannot claim abroad what you do not claim domestically.
He said, “If a country expects to demand compensation for an oil spill or accident, it needs to have a domestic framework to show if that happened domestically, they would be claiming response and remediation and that is very important to bear in mind.”
The ASEA Director said that setting the appropriate obligations to ensure oil and gas operators are capable of responding in a timely manner to oil spills is hinged on two things: insurance policies and making it mandatory for the operators to have sufficient technical capacity to respond to emergencies.
He said that this means the country must have trained personnel, materials and equipment to be deployed within the first hours of an emergency.
Regules said, “This is very important; it is a lesson that can be learned from any of the major oil spills that occurred around the world. You can contain a crisis more efficiently when you are prepared. So making those two things, insurance policies and technical capacity, mandatory is the ingredient for preparing for an emergency in this industry…”
In sharing a bit of the Mexican experience, the Oil and Gas regulator also said that it would also be important for Guyana to have a robust system in place to review insurance policies.
He said, “In Mexico, you must have an insurance policy before a permit is granted. In fact, companies have to comply with our insurance regulations and our SEMS (Safety Environmental Management Systems) Regulations.”
The ASEA Director said that the oil operators also have to go through a rigorous Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and provide an appropriate design for their project. He said that once they comply with all those things, and a thorough review is done, then it is a go.
VAGUE TERMS
In the Production Sharing Agreement (PSA) signed between the Government of Guyana and USA oil giant, ExxonMobil, there is no provision covering any adverse impact on fishing grounds and coastal communities or on neighbouring countries.
This alarming observation was first pointed out by Chartered Accountant, Chris Ram, and political Commentator, Ramon Gaskin. The two have been extremely critical of the vague terms in the contract especially as it relates to environmental protection.
Ram in his recent writings noted that Article 20.2 of Guyana’s 2016 Oil Agreement deals with Insurance in respect of, but not limited to, assets, pollution, third parties and employees. The Attorney-at-Law pointed out that the Agreement does not require any loss of production insurance as will apply in the case of any major disruption of production or environmental accidents.
He said that while this provision is absent from the 2016 Agreement, the 1999 Agreement which was signed by the Jagan administration, allowed for insurance to be taken out by Esso Exploration and Production Guyana Limited’s affiliate insurance company. Esso is a subsidiary of ExxonMobil.
Ram stated, “That requirement has been changed and now allows the Contractor to have the right to self-insure against the risks identified. This is a major concession by (Natural Resources Minister, Raphael) Trotman on an issue that only specialist lawyers know about. What it means in practice is that anyone seeking to make an insurance claim will have to lodge that claim against Esso, CNOOC/Nexen or Hess, all of which are external companies.
Those potential claimants must thank Raphael Trotman for making their chances even more difficult to succeed.”
JAGDEO ADDING MORE DANGER TO GUYANA AND THE REGION
Apr 18, 2024
SportsMax – West Indies captain Hayley Matthews has been named Wisden’s leading Twenty20 Cricketer for 2023, as she topped all and sundry, including her male counterparts. Alan Gardner looks...Kaieteur News – Compliments of the Ministry of Education, our secondary school children are being treated to a stage... more
By Sir Ronald Sanders Waterfalls Magazine – On April 10, the Permanent Council of the Organization of American States... more
Freedom of speech is our core value at Kaieteur News. If the letter/e-mail you sent was not published, and you believe that its contents were not libellous, let us know, please contact us by phone or email.
Feel free to send us your comments and/or criticisms.
Contact: 624-6456; 225-8452; 225-8458; 225-8463; 225-8465; 225-8473 or 225-8491.
Or by Email: [email protected] / [email protected]