Latest update January 15th, 2025 3:45 AM
Latest News
- Auditors given 5 months to audit Exxon’s US$19.6B expenditure
- Bar Association calls for immediate appointment of Chancellor and Chief Justice
- Gaza ceasefire ‘closer than ever’, Hamas says it is still awaiting Israeli maps
- Pigeons shut down Charlestown Secondary School
- One confirmed dead in Bartica bike accidents
Tax arrears… PPP against proposal for GRA to take monies from taxpayers’ bank accounts
Former Attorney General, Anil Nandlall
The Opposition has vowed to intensely scrutinize a planned proposal of the administration to “garnish” funds from citizens and businesses if they are in arrears of taxes.
Former Attorney General, Anil Nandlall, yesterday said that Monday’s pronouncement by Finance Minister, Winston Jordan, in his budget speech to the National Assembly is causing worry.
“That the Income Tax Act will be revised to authorize the GRA (Guyana Revenue Authority) to “garnish” funds from bank accounts held by tax payers who have outstanding tax arrears has caused great anxiety and concerns both to the business community as well as the ordinary citizen,” Nandlall said yesterday.
“You will recall that earlier this year, the Government passed a law that allows the GRA to go into a person’s bank account without notifying that person and without providing any reasons. Now again, we see another attempt to invade the privacy of persons’ bank accounts by this Government.”
Nandlall, whose party – the People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) – lost the May 2015 general elections after a more than two decades stay in power, said that these signals drive fear in the minds of every single Guyanese.
“It also does not inspire the confidence of the business community both locally and internationally. No one will ever be comfortable with the tax authorities having a power to raid their bank accounts with no reason given. It simply smacks of authoritarianism and interference with property rights which are protected by the constitution. After all, money is property.
“In my humble view, this is not only a misuse and abuse of garnishment but it is also draconian.”
What is of greater concern, the former minister said, is the intention to “garnish” people’s accounts and to seize from there, monies and to apply those monies to liquidate outstanding taxes.
“In my humble view, this is not only a misuse and abuse of garnishment but it is also draconian. Garnishment is a proceeding whereby a person’s property or credits in the possession or under the control of another, are applied to the former’s debt to a third person. Simply put, if A owes B and C owes A, B can garnish the money which C owes to A from C, in satisfaction of the debt which A owes to B.”
According to Nandlall, clearly this is not what the Minister is speaking about. “The Minister is speaking about a situation where if A owes taxes to GRA, GRA will have a right to go into A’s bank account and take money therefrom in satisfaction of the taxes which are owed. This is not and has nothing to do with garnishing.”
This, he said, is simply the seizing of monies in satisfaction of taxes owed without due process.
Significantly, garnishing is a court-driven process where all the parties concerned are legally represented or, at least given the opportunity to retain counsel and are afforded a fair and adequate hearing before a Judge. These important safeguards and fundamental aspects of due process are conspicuously absent from the Minister’s formulation.
“I presume that a bill will have to be tabled in the National Assembly conferring this power upon the GRA. Unless this bill meets the litmus test of constitutionality, fairness and due process, it will be vehemently opposed by the PPP in the National Assembly,” Nandlall vowed.
The $250B budget, which was presented on Monday, has introduced a number of new taxes and promises tough actions against tax evaders.
Similar Articles
THE BLUNT OF THE DAY
Sports
Features/Columnists
Members of the National Assembly should exercise civility towards their peers
Peeping Tom… Kaieteur News- The following column was published two years ago in response to the same controversy that... more
Clarifying misconceptions about the Panama Canal
Sir Ronald Sanders (Antigua and Barbuda’s Ambassador to the US and the OAS) By Sir Ronald Sanders Kaieteur News–... more
Weekend Cartoon
