Latest update April 19th, 2024 12:59 AM
May 05, 2013 Editorial
In a society such as ours, social capital is a crucial ingredient in our thrust for development. For our purposes, we can accept Francis Fukuyama’s proposal that social capital is “the ability of people to work together for common purposes in groups and organizations” or alternatively that it “can be defined simply as the existence of a certain set of informal values or norms shared among members of a group that permit cooperation among them”.
This year will be the tenth commemoration of Arrival Day as a public holiday, and maybe it is time that we reflect on the event as far as increasing social capital. For several years before, several Indian-Guyanese groups had been agitating for a public holiday to commemorate the arrival of their ancestors to this land. It was contended that the holiday would assist in nation building by reminding the other groups making up the Guyanese mosaic of their impact and contribution to this land. This was expected, in effect, to increase our social capital.
The issue was debated extensively in the letters pages and editorials of the national press and demonstrated that there were deep seated doubts of the motives of those demanding the holiday. Members of African groups especially felt that the commemoration was triumphalist and, by implication, devalued the contributions of other groups.
The issue was finally submitted to a Parliamentary Committee and after extensive written and oral submissions from groups and individuals, it recommended that the day be declared a holiday. The PNC did not participate in either the deliberations of the Committee or in the later Parliamentary vote on the Committee’s recommendation. It objected to the presence of the then Minister of Home Affairs but noted that it had no problem with the holiday to acknowledge the contributions of “Indo Guyanese”.
But somewhere between the recommendation and the Presidential approval, the holiday was declared and designated as “Arrival Day”. It appeared that the government was looking to widen the significance of the day to encompass other groups that had also “arrived”.
Maybe it was trying to expand the potential of the day to increase “social capital”. In and of itself, there was nothing wrong with the idea but the end-process was quite undemocratic since every group that made submissions on the May 5 proposed holiday had designated it as “Indian Arrival Day”.
It is apposite to note that none of the other groups that arrived as “indentured labourers” in substantial numbers – Portuguese and Chinese – first did so on May 5. There were some objections but the commemorations began in 2004. What has happened since is that Arrival Day, just as had been the practice, is being commemorated exclusively by Indian-Guyanese. Recently, there have been several functions involving the now growing population of Chinese that was specifically scheduled for January 12, the day the first Chinese immigrants actually landed in Guyana.
The question that was implicitly posed at the beginning must now be raised: has “Arrival Day” increased or decreased our social capital? From where we stand, it seems to have increased the internal social capital of Indian Guyanese but not the external ones with other groups in the society. In fact there appears to an undercurrent of resentment by some non-Indians at what they perceive to be an effort to foist the holiday to include them without their permission.
Maybe like Trinidad discovered, it might be best to call a spade a spade: they reversed themselves on “Arrival Day” and quickly made it into “Indian Arrival Day”. Quite interestingly, there has been a steadily growing participation in the commemoration functions there by non-Indians. We can take hope in the course that Emancipation Day has taken here where it is accepted by every group in the county that the event commemorated is on national significance and has lasting significance.
The point is that social capital cannot be forced onto people. Whatever norms are sought to be inculcated, will be more acceptable when all the cards are on the table. Indian Arrival Day, anyone?
Please share this to every Guyanese including your house cats.
Apr 19, 2024
SportsMax – West Indies Women’s captain Hayley Matthews delivered a stellar all-round performance to lead her team to a commanding 113-run victory over Pakistan Women in the first One Day...Kaieteur News – For years, the disciples of Bharrat Jagdeo have woven a narrative of economic success during his tenure... more
By Sir Ronald Sanders Waterfalls Magazine – On April 10, the Permanent Council of the Organization of American States... more
Freedom of speech is our core value at Kaieteur News. If the letter/e-mail you sent was not published, and you believe that its contents were not libellous, let us know, please contact us by phone or email.
Feel free to send us your comments and/or criticisms.
Contact: 624-6456; 225-8452; 225-8458; 225-8463; 225-8465; 225-8473 or 225-8491.
Or by Email: [email protected] / [email protected]